Part 1: Four Navy Coats Under the Table
“Mister, could you pretend to be our daddy? Just until that man leaves?”
The whisper came from somewhere near my left shoe. I was halfway through an email to a lender in Springfield, my thumb hovering over send. When I looked down, a small girl in a navy wool coat was kneeling on the tile beneath my table.
Before I could answer, three more crawled in after her. They wore the same coats with the same brass buttons. The smallest one wrapped both hands around my trouser leg like she was gripping a railing on a moving train.
Near the front door, a woman in a camel trench coat stood with her shoulder half-turned to a tall man in a charcoal suit. He kept talking. She kept trying to step away, and every time she did, he moved with her, polite as a dance partner and twice as hard to lose.
I had spent twenty-two years becoming the kind of man other men hesitated to call back. Bankers rehearsed before meetings with me. Aldermen chose their words carefully.
Not one of them would have dared to ask me what that little girl just had.
I said yes.
I figured it would take ten minutes.
My name is Nathaniel Mercer. I was forty-six that October, and eating lunch alone had stopped feeling lonely years earlier. Now it just felt efficient.
That Thursday I’d come late to Bramble & Rye on Kinzie Street in River North, a quiet place with brass lamps and bad parking. It was 2:40 in the afternoon. Rain streaked the front windows, and people outside hunched under umbrellas the color of wet slate.
I always took the corner table. It let me see the room without the room seeing much of me.
My firm, Mercer Lake Capital, owned apartment buildings and commercial property in four Illinois counties. That meant my days were full of people who weren’t used to hearing no. My staff called me exacting. My competitors used less polite words.
Neither label kept me up at night. What did was the robotics showcase I’d missed the previous spring. My son, Owen, had texted me a photo of his trophy at 8:52 p.m. while I was still in a conference room on Wacker Drive.
None of that had prepared me for four children under my table.
The oldest looked about ten. She had dark brown hair in a tidy braid, gray eyes, and the tight, careful mouth of a kid who had already appointed herself in charge of things no kid should be in charge of.
The next one, maybe eight, held her younger sister’s hand. The third, around seven, kept peeking toward the door as if she were counting the seconds. The littlest couldn’t have been more than five.
I set my phone down. “Well. This is new. Are you girls looking for someone?”
The oldest shook her head. “We’re looking for someone who can help our mom.”
“Is your mom here?”
Four small fingers pointed toward the door.
“That’s her,” the oldest said. “And the man next to her doesn’t listen when she says no.”
I studied the woman more carefully. Her posture was calm and her chin was level. But her right hand was clamped around the strap of her purse so hard that her knuckles had gone pale.
“What are your names?”
“I’m Harper. That’s Willa, that’s Phoebe, and that’s Nell.”
Nell hugged my knee harder. “Please be our daddy for a little while. We promise we’ll be good.”
There was nothing manipulative in it. She just meant it, and that made it worse.
“Why do you need a pretend father?”
Harper glanced at the man in the suit. “Because Mr. Prescott thinks Mom needs to marry him. He says four girls need a man to make the family complete.”
Willa frowned. “But our family was already complete before he started saying that.”
Something pulled tight under my ribs.
My wife, Claire, had died five years before. Since then, I’d lost count of the people who told me my house needed a woman in it. My sister said it over Thanksgiving pie. A board member said it at a golf outing. Once, a neighbor said it on our front porch while Owen, nine years old, stood right behind me holding the screen door.
They meant well, mostly. They almost never thought about how it sounded to the kid who was listening.
I turned my phone facedown on the table.
“All right, ladies. I can help for a few minutes.”
Nell’s whole face lit up. “Really? You can be our daddy?”
“Only until your mom gets things sorted out.”
Harper narrowed her eyes at me. “Are you sure? Mr. Prescott is very stubborn.”
“I’ve dealt with stubborn people before.”
She considered that, then nodded once, as though she’d approved a contract. That was when I noticed she was keeping one arm pressed tight against the front of her coat. A hard, square corner pushed the wool out at an angle, and she wouldn’t let go of it even to climb out from under the table.
I coaxed them into the open. Nell took the chair beside me. The other three gathered around like a family council called to order.
Then their mother turned, saw the empty spot where her daughters should have been, and scanned the room. Her eyes landed on my table.
She was across the café in about four strides.
Before she could say a word, Nell beamed up at her and announced, loud enough for the espresso machine to hear, “Mommy, he’s not a stranger. He’s our new pretend daddy!”
Behind her, the man in the charcoal suit turned around. He looked straight at me, and his smile stopped halfway.
Part 2: A Dead Battery and a Folder of Half-Truths
For a few seconds, nobody said anything at all.
A blush climbed from the collar of the woman’s sweater all the way up to her hairline. “Nell, sweetheart, you can’t just pick someone to be your father.”
“But Harper said we needed help, and he looked nice.”
“I’m so sorry.” She turned to me. “They know they’re not supposed to walk up to strangers.”
“They didn’t walk. They crawled. Technically a different rule.” I stood and offered my hand. “Nathaniel Mercer.”
“Eliza Whitcomb.” Her grip was firm despite everything. “I’ve heard of you.”
“Hopefully nothing too terrible.”
“Mostly that you’re very difficult to negotiate with.”
“Only when the other person isn’t listening.”
Her smile faded a little, because the man in the suit had arrived at her elbow.
He was about forty-five, tall and polished, with a burgundy tie and the easy confidence of someone who usually got what he wanted. “Eliza, we still haven’t finished discussing the proposal.”
“I told you I needed to check on my daughters, Russell.”
He finally looked at me directly. “Nathaniel Mercer. I didn’t realize you were here.”
“Russell Prescott.” We’d never done business, but Chicago’s development world is a small room with thin walls. I knew his name, and he obviously knew mine.
“I hope the girls haven’t interrupted your lunch.”
See more on the next page