Have you ever stepped outside into your backyard and noticed a security camera mounted on your neighbor’s house pointing in your direction? At first, it may seem harmless. After all, everyone has the right to protect their home. But when a camera appears to be watching your private outdoor space, it is completely reasonable to wonder where the line between home security and invasion of privacy begins.
The answer depends on several factors, including where the camera is pointed, what it can actually see, whether it records audio, and the privacy laws that apply where you live.
A neighbor generally has the right to install security cameras on their own property to protect their home, vehicles, family, and belongings. A camera may also capture portions of neighboring property incidentally because modern security cameras often have wide viewing angles.
For example, your neighbor might install a camera above their garage to monitor their driveway. If part of your backyard happens to appear in the corner of the recording, that doesn’t automatically mean the camera is being used illegally.
The situation becomes more concerning when the camera appears to be deliberately positioned to monitor a private area of your property.
There is an important difference between a camera that happens to capture part of your yard and one that is intentionally aimed at a secluded patio, bedroom window, swimming pool, or another location where you have taken reasonable steps to maintain privacy.
This is where the concept of a reasonable expectation of privacy becomes important.
A front yard visible from a public street generally has a different level of privacy than a fenced backyard hidden from public view. The more private and secluded an area is, the more important the circumstances surrounding the recording may become.
The technology used by the camera can matter as well. Some modern home security systems offer high-resolution video, remote viewing, motion detection, night vision, pan-and-tilt controls, and powerful zoom capabilities. A camera capable of seeing details from a considerable distance can raise different privacy concerns than a basic camera monitoring a front door.
Audio recording deserves special attention.
See more on the next page