“Please tell me you are not serious,” she said.
I came out of my room. “It’s my prom dress.”
And she burst out laughing. Loud this time, real delight in it, her head actually tipping back. “That?” she said, pointing. “That patchwork thing? Oh, that’s — no. No, you’re joking.”
Noah’s door opened down the hall. He came out and stood next to me. He’d heard.
Carla looked back and forth between the two of us, and then she pressed her hand flat against her chest, like I’d wounded her somehow. Like my existence was a personal injury she was bravely enduring.
“If you wear that,” she said, “the entire school is going to laugh at you. You get that, right? You’ll be the girl who showed up to prom in a pile of old rags. They’ll be talking about it for years.”
“It’s fine,” I said.
“No, it’s really not fine.” She waved her hand at the dress, dismissing it, dismissing all those nights, all those pinpricked fingertips. “Honestly? It looks pathetic. It looks like something out of a dumpster.”
And that’s when Noah said, very quietly, “I made it.”
The temperature in the hallway dropped. Carla turned her head slowly and looked at him fully, and I watched the thing light up behind her eyes, the thing that always lit up when she found a fresh, soft target.
“You made it,” she repeated.
He lifted his chin. I could see what it cost him to do it. “Yeah.”
She smiled. The slow one. The kind of smile that’s built specifically to hurt you as slowly as possible. “Well,” she said. “That explains a lot, doesn’t it.”
I stepped forward. “Enough.”
But that only delighted her more. Me talking back was a bonus round. “Oh, this is going to be good,” she said. “You’re going to walk into that gym in a dress your little brother stitched out of garbage, like some kind of charity case, and you actually believe people are going to what — clap? Cheer? Sweetheart. They’re going to eat you alive. And you’re going to deserve it for being dumb enough to wear it.”
I was quiet for a second. And then I said, calm as I could make it, “I’d rather wear something made with love than something bought by stealing from kids.”
The hallway went dead silent.
Something flickered across Carla’s face. Just for a second, I thought maybe I’d actually gotten through to some buried human part of her. Then her eyes went hard and flat as a pair of coins.
“Get out of my sight,” she said, “before I really tell you what I think of you.”
I took the dress into my room. And I heard her go down the stairs, and I heard her on the phone a few minutes later, her voice carrying up through the vents the way it always did.
“You have to come early,” she was saying to somebody. “Trust me. I need witnesses for this. It is going to be the funniest thing you’ve ever seen.”
She was planning to come. To prom. To watch. She was inviting an audience.
I sat on my bed and looked at the dress and I made a decision. I wasn’t going to tell Noah. He’d worked too hard, and he was too fragile still, and I wasn’t going to let her steal even one ounce of his pride before he’d gotten to feel it. Whatever happened at that gym, he was going to walk in there believing he’d made me something beautiful.
Because he had.
—
The three weeks of secret sewing had been almost fun, in a way. A shared thing, ours, hidden from her. But the days right before prom were tense in a different way, because now Carla knew, and now Carla was planning something, and living in that house started to feel like living under a storm cloud that wouldn’t break.
She made comments constantly. Little ones, all day long. “Make sure you get a picture of the rags for me.” “I wonder if the school has a dress code for burlap.” She’d say them and then watch to see if they landed, and I got very good at keeping my face still, at giving her nothing.
Noah was the one I worried about. He was so happy about the dress, so quietly, carefully proud, and I could see her comments chipping at him. One night at dinner she said, apropos of nothing, “You know, my sister’s boy plays football. A real sport. I always wonder what your father would’ve made of the sewing thing,” and Noah put down his fork and left the table and didn’t come back, and I found him later sitting on the back step in the dark.
“Don’t listen to her,” I said, sitting down next to him.
“Dad wouldn’t have cared,” Noah said. “Right? That I sew?”
“Dad,” I said, “would have told everyone he met. He would have been so annoying about it. He’d have a picture of that dress as his phone background and he’d show it to the guy at the gas station.”
Noah laughed, but it was wet, and he wiped his face fast. “I miss him.”
“Me too.”
“I miss Mom.”
“Me too.” I bumped his shoulder with mine. “But we’ve got her coming to prom. That’s something. That’s more than most people get.”
He nodded. And we sat out there in the dark for a while, not talking, just being two kids who’d lost too much, holding on to the one thing we’d managed to make out of it.
My best friend Tessa knew the whole story. I’d told her everything, the money, the fight, the secret dress, all of it. And two days before prom she called me and said her mom wanted to do our pictures at their house, and that Noah should come too, and that I should get ready over there.
“My mom said, and I quote, ‘that poor girl is not getting dressed for prom in that woman’s house,’” Tessa told me. “So it’s decided. You’re coming here.”
I almost cried. It was such a small thing and it meant so much. Somebody’s mom, looking out for me. It had been a long time.
—
Prom night, I got ready at Tessa’s house, and her mom did my hair, and when I put the dress on and came out of the bathroom, Tessa’s mom put her hand over her mouth and her eyes filled up.
“Oh, honey,” she said. “Oh, look at you.”
Noah was there, in a borrowed jacket that was slightly too big for him. He helped me zip up the back of the dress, and I could feel his hands shaking against my spine.
“Hey,” I said, turning around to face him. “Look at me. This is the best dress at that whole school tonight. You know that, right?”
“You have to say that,” he mumbled. “You’re my sister.”
“No. I mean it. And if one single person laughs at it, I will find them, and I will haunt them for the rest of their natural lives.”
That got a real smile out of him, finally. “Good,” he said.
Tessa’s mom drove us. And the whole way there my stomach was in knots, because I knew Carla was going to be there, somewhere, phone out, with her little audience of witnesses, waiting for the moment it all fell apart.
I spotted her almost immediately when we walked in. Back corner, near the wall, standing with two other women I half-recognized. Her phone was already up, already pointed at me, filming, before I’d taken ten steps into the gym.
Tessa saw me clock her. “What are you looking at?” She followed my eyes. “Wait. Is that your stepmom? Why is she filming you? Why is she even here?”
“She came to watch me get humiliated,” I said. “She brought friends.”
Tessa’s whole face went cold in a way I’d never seen on her before. “Your stepmom,” she said, “is genuinely evil.”
“Yeah,” I said. “I’ve been saying.”
But then the strangest thing started to happen.
Nobody laughed.
People looked. They definitely looked. But it wasn’t the way Carla wanted. A girl from my choir class came right over, eyes wide. “Okay, wait,” she said. “Is your dress denim? Like, actual jeans?”
“My brother made it,” I said.
“Shut up. Your brother made that? Where’s your brother? He needs to make me one.”
Another girl came up. “I’ve been staring at your dress from across the room for ten minutes. Where did you get it? Is it, like, a designer thing?”
See more on the next page